Basil and Oregano by
Melissa CapriglioneMy rating:
3 of 5 starsI really wanted to rate this four star but man, that ending. It was so rushed and had problems that I'll get into later. I think some of the issues in this is because of the limits of traditional sequential art publishing. You have X number of pages, fit it in there or it doesn't get told. This might have been better as a webtoon where the pace could have been slowed down and the characters developed. So many of the characters are so underdeveloped they feel like they're there for diversity's sake and no other reason.
Our point of view character is Basil, a young girl who has to get Top Student rating or else her two dads get a 200K bill for her tuition. There is no explanation as to why a magical culinary school is priced so only multimillionaires can afford it and one of the weak parts of the final chapters are almost everyone is on scholarship so why aren't Basil's besties Villy (non-binary) and Addy (trans black girl) taking this more seriously? Why isn't everyone cutting each other's throats and not just Xynthia who is your typical mean girl. We have no idea until the end she's doing it because she can't afford school either. She just comes off as your typical high school snobby mean girl. In fact the only other mention we have of price is the coffee house girl who longs to go but can't afford it.
On day one Basil and her buddies meet up with the new student Arabella Oregano, daughter of a famous/rich magiculinary artist. Basil is immediately smitten with Arabella and the bulk of the graphic novel is divided between their cooking classes, their romance and Xynthia's snobby bitchery.
Until a) we find out Arabella's secret b)Xynthia and Basil find out too. Now Basil has to make a choice and if she chooses Arabella and it's discovered she'll be tossed out the competition and will need to come up with two hundred thousand dollars. Xynthia on the other hand decides she can't just go tell the teachers (why not we have no idea because this feels like something easily proven) but instead decides to take an elaborate revenge plot approach.
And this is where everything falls apart for me and why I couldn't go to 4 stars. I can live with Villy and Abby being half forgotten (sad but this is Basil and Arabella's romance saga so... still they should have been better developed) Xynthia's spell proves there's more than food magic out there so why is food magic so important to these kids? Arabella would rather cook the old fashioned way but no one does that any more. Why? Does everyone have some level of food magic? Then why is this school so crazy expensive?
I could live with that too but as expected Xynthia's spell goes horribly awry and people could have been killed. It's only because of Arabella that they don't. The teachers do squat all (other than to try to clear the food festival grounds to people aren't hurt and then...maybe they'll do something).
Okay consider there to be minor spoilers from here out The teachers DO have offensive magic but the students aren't at that level yet. Um WHY would a freaking chef need combat magic? And honestly how hard would it be to squirt hot pepper juice into someone's eyes? We see them doing similar things while cooking.
Now I expected Basil and Arabella to triumphant because this is a YA romance and they're our heroes but the final chapter is such a let down. Yes they succeed but NOTHING happens to Xynthia. Even before her lame apology to Basil (her family life is in turmoil and she can't afford this school either, which fine yes that will cause people to act out but it's also not an excuse for nearly killing people), she's right there are the end of festival/end of school term meeting. She faced zero consequences for her actions. Cue me screaming into the void. I get so tired of this. You do shitty things and people just shrug it off. Fine, Basil can be the bigger person and forgive but why did the school not expel Xynthia for nearly killing everyone at the festival or at least trying to ruin her competition so she could win?
And the other star-losing plot point is the school said oops no one won the festival (because it was ruined) no one gets top student so you ALL owe tuition. WTF? First off only 2 students top can get the scholarship (because you have to be top student in two quarters, see what I mean by why aren't more students out to destroy their classmates) and now everyone is on the hook for the money. The students revolt in a passionate why are you hurting your future by destroying us and the school goes hmm you're right, no tuition for anyone. What? laughs. This was so dumb. And all the wealthy donors sitting in at this festivity are all you know what, kids be right here I'll pay for them. And then the poor kid from the coffee house is there 'wooo I can go to this school now.' Why is she there? Is she catering this event? The end is such a hot mess.
There is a sweet epilogue though. Overall, this is sweet, cute and I'm glad I read it but the world building and pacing required some work. I really enjoyed the art. It fits the tone of the story and it's very well done. We also get a diversity of body types which we don't always see.
View all my reviews